NEW YORK STATE MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
                                         FAILURE TO DIAGNOSE CANCER CASES

A medical malpractice plaintiff must prove three elements:

1) negligence,  The physician had a duty to perform A (as shown by medical texts or testimony of a fellow physician) but failed to do so.  Generally, the plaintiff must establish the standard and explain how it was violated, 

2) damage or injury   The plaintiff must show that there was a serious injury.  Medical malpractice claims are rarely brought for small errors or injuries.   

3)  proximate cause The patient must relate the physician's error to the damages which were suffered.   Some errors may be irrelevant.  

One court stated: "The elements of proof in an action to recover damages for medical malpractice are (1) deviation or departure from accepted practice, and (2) evidence that such departure was a proximate cause of injury or damage. To carry the burden of proving a prima facie case, the plaintiff must generally show that the defendant's negligence was a substantial factor in producing the injury (see, Derdiarian v Felix Contr. Corp., 51 NY2d 308).  Expert testimony is necessary to prove a deviation from accepted standards of medical care and to establish proximate cause unless the matter is one which is within the experience and observation of the ordinary juror (see, Koehler v Schwartz, 48 NY2d 807). The consequence of failure to diagnose cancer is not a matter within the ordinary expertise of a lay person and requires expert testimony (see, Fiore v Galang, 64 NY2d 999).

The record contains sufficient evidence to support the Conclusion that the defendant departed from good and accepted medical practice in failing to send cyst fluid for analysis and in failing to follow up after the plaintiff failed to keep several appointments. However, the trial court properly granted the defendant's motion to dismiss the action because there was no expert testimony causally linking the defendant's negligence with any delay in the diagnosis of her breast cancer or with any injury that was separate and apart from the underlying cancer. 
Lyons v. McCauley, 252 A.D.2d 516, 675 N.Y.S.2d 375 (1998)
 

MEDICAL MALPRACTICE LINKS  

Failure to diagnose cancer, doctor's defenses Malpractice and standard of care
Failure to Detect Lung Cancer claims
What is cancer (chapter one from our upcoming book, A Complete Guide to Lung Cancer) 
medical malpractice and standard of care (a journal discussing medical malpractice standards of care including failure to diagnose cancer)
New York medical malpractice claims

medical malpractice lung cancer claims    cancer malpractice statute of limitations               
New York Cancer Malpractice claims       medical malpractice and clinical practice guidelines
New Jersey cancer malpractice claims     medical malpractice liability
Medical malpractice jury instruction        New York Medical malpractice law 
medical malpractice pre-existing cause    workers' compensation doctor liability for malpractice
cancer, malpractice and informed consent

How to contact us:
Law Offices of Howard A. Gutman,
230 Route 206, Mount Olive, New Jersey 07836
(973) 598-1980, E-mail Howian@aol.com 

FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION  

keywords: medical malpractice, claim,  attorney, failure to diagnose cancer, negligence, malpractice, delayed diagnosis, standard of care, 
missed diagnosis, New Jersey medical malpractice lawyer, New York medical malpractice lawyer.

About Us
 

Mr. Gutman is the author of lung cancer and mesothelioma, 480 page book which reviews chemotherapy, gene therapy, radiation, treatment for lung cancer, and medical malpractice questions.   He served as a caregiver for a family member with lung cancer, was a member of the board of directors of a leading cancer support group, and is an attorney specializing in lung cancer legal issues.  He combines the intellectual knowledge of someone who handles issues of lung cancer with the personal approach of someone who has dealt with cancer and confronted many of the difficult questions patients and family members confront.     
                       

Free consultation on your medical malpractice claim

This page is intended to provide general information and is not intended to provide legal advice regarding any individual claim.    

keywords, medical malpractice, failure to diagnose cancer, medical malpractice claim, New York state, law, suit, attorney, 

Failure to diagnose cancer, doctor's defenses

Medical Malpractice Cancer Home Page